Mad Money Machine

by Paul Douglas Boyer

ps06

NEW! Get Ready to get SmackedDown!

Join the 2007 MadMoneyMachine.com Portfolio Smackdown at

http://vse.marketwatch.com/Game/StartViewGame.aspx?id=MadMoneyMachine.com

You will get a pretend $100,000 to invest in 2007 and see if you can beat the Indexfolioâ„¢ 100

The 2006 Portfolio Smackdown!

We have a winner: The MONEY MACHINE beats the MAD MONEY!

Yearly return for 2006:

ETF Portfolio 20.6%
Portfolio of Select
Jim Cramer Featured Stocks
-0.2% Lost money!
IFA Index Portfolio 100
(net of IFA and DFA fees)
as of 29 December 2006
22.51% GREAT YEAR!!!!

Get more details about the IFA Index Portfolio 100 at Index Funds Advisors (ifa.com).

The Cramer portfolio reached a high of $116,753.79 on 10 May.

Chart
I’ll update this chart every once in a while. I just started keeping track of portfolio values in late March, but went back to get some at the end of January and February also.

SUMMARY VIEW
MONEY MACHINE: 2006 Portfolio of Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)
Name Ticker % Gain Total_Value
VG Total Market VTI 13.7% $ 22,714.02
VG Mid-Cap VO 12.4% $ 11,257.65
VG Small-Cap VB 14.4% $ 11,440.80
PowerShares Micro-Cap PZI 17.9% $ 11,787.60
VG REIT VNQ 29.3% $ 12,936.00
VG Materials VAW 17.6% $ 11,775.17
VG European VGK 29.6% $ 12,950.40
VG Pacific VPL 9.2% $ 10,901.08
VG Emerging Market VWO 27.1% $ 12,691.96
Cash     $ 2,229.21
    20.6% $ 120,611.89
       
       
MAD MONEY: 2006 Portfolio of Select Jim Cramer Featured Stocks
Name Ticker % Gain Total_Value
Sears Holdings Corporation SHLD 9.2% $ 10,747.52
Halliburton Company HAL -10.6% $ 8,383.50
ALTRIA GROUP MO 2.7% $ 11,156.60
Open   0.0% $ –
Genzyme Corporation GENZ 3.6% $ 10,222.28
Johnson & Johnson JNJ 1.1% $ 10,827.28
The Boeing Company BA 7.0% $ 10,571.96
Google Inc. GOOG -5.5% $ 8,749.12
J.C. Penney Company, Inc. JCP 21.3% $ 10,056.80
TALISMAN ENERGY INC TLM -3.6% $ 9,633.33
Cash     $ 9,992.82
    -0.2% $ 99,805.21
                     
                     
DETAILED VIEW              
Indexes                    
Name Ticker _Price_Paid_   Shrs Buy_Price LatestPrice %Gain Total_Value Buy Date  
DIAMONDS TRUST SER 1 DIA $ 106.95   1 $ 106.95 $ 124.41 17.5% $ 125.70 12/30/2005  
S&P DEP RECEIPTS SPY $ 124.51   1 $ 124.51 $ 141.62 14.6% $ 142.69 12/30/2005  
Nasdaq-100 Trust, Series I – Nasdaq-100 Shares QQQQ $ 40.41   1 $ 40.41 $ 43.16 6.9% $ 43.21 12/30/2005  
Alpha Hedged Strategies ALPHX $ 12.13   1 $ 12.13 $ 13.24 9.2% $ 13.24 12/30/2005  
                     
ETF Portfolio                    
Name Ticker _Price_Paid_ Fee Shrs Buy_Price LatestPrice %Gain Total_Value Buy Date Cat
VG Total Market VTI $ 19,979.46 $8 162 $ 123.33 $ 140.21 13.7% $ 22,714.02 12/30/2005 LC
VG Mid-Cap VO $ 10,014.55 $8 155 $ 64.61 $ 72.63 12.4% $ 11,257.65 12/30/2005 MC
VG Small-Cap VB $ 10,004.40 $8 168 $ 59.55 $ 68.10 14.4% $ 11,440.80 12/30/2005 SC
PowerShares Micro-Cap PZI $ 9,999.00 $8 660 $ 15.15 $ 17.86 17.9% $ 11,787.60 12/30/2005 mC
VG REIT VNQ $ 10,006.08 $8 168 $ 59.56 $ 77.00 29.3% $ 12,936.00 12/30/2005 REIT
VG Materials VAW $ 10,009.98 $8 167 $ 59.94 $ 70.51 17.6% $ 11,775.17 12/30/2005 Mat
VG European VGK $ 9,994.00 $8 190 $ 52.60 $ 68.16 29.6% $ 12,950.40 12/30/2005 EURO
VG Pacific VPL $ 9,985.96 $8 164 $ 60.89 $ 66.47 9.2% $ 10,901.08 12/30/2005 PAC
VG Emerging Market VWO $ 9,984.32 $8 164 $ 60.88 $ 77.39 27.1% $ 12,691.96 12/30/2005 EM
Cash   $ 2,229.21           $ 2,229.21    
TOTAL   $ 102,206.96 $72       20.6% $ 120,611.89    
                     
2006 Portfolio of Select Jim Cramer Featured Stocks                
Name Ticker Price_Paid Fee Shrs Buy_Price LatestPrice % Gain Total_Value Buy Date Cat
Sears Holdings Corporation SHLD $ 9,844.48 $8 64 $ 153.82 $ 167.93 9.2% $ 10,747.52 5/31/2006 1
Halliburton Company HAL $ 9,373.05 $8 270 $ 34.72 $ 31.05 -10.6% $ 8,383.50 3/22/2006 2
ALTRIA GROUP MO $ 10,858.90 $8 130 $ 83.53 $ 85.82 2.7% $ 11,156.60 11/28/2006 3
Open                   4
Genzyme Corporation GENZ $ 9,865.38 $8 166 $ 59.43 $ 61.58 3.6% $ 10,222.28 5/31/2006 5
Johnson & Johnson JNJ $ 10,712.48 $8 164 $ 65.32 $ 66.02 1.1% $ 10,827.28 11/27/2006 6
The Boeing Company BA $ 9,882.95 $8 119 $ 83.05 $ 88.84 7.0% $ 10,571.96 5/31/2006 7
Google Inc. GOOG $ 9,255.09 $8 19 $ 487.11 $ 460.48 -5.5% $ 8,749.12 12/6/2006 8
J.C. Penney Company, Inc. JCP $ 8,290.10 $8 130 $ 63.77 $ 77.36 21.3% $ 10,056.80 8/2/2006 9
TALISMAN ENERGY INC TLM $ 9,994.32 $8 567 $ 17.63 $ 16.99 -3.6% $ 9,633.33 12/30/2005 10
Cash   $ 9,992.82         0.0% $ 9,992.82    
TOTAL   $ 98,069.57 $536       -0.2% $ 99,805.21    
                     
PREVIOUS HOLDINGS                    
Votorantim Celulose e Papel S.A (ADR) VCP   $16   $ 12.29 $ 19.61     12/30/2005 1
Southern Copper Corporation PCU   $16   $ 81.81 $ 53.89     3/6/2006 1
UnitedHealth Group Inc. UNH   $16   $ 43.62 $ 53.73     5/23/2006 1
ENGlobal Corporation ENG   $16   $ 8.40 $ 6.43     12/30/2005 2
Nabors Industries Ltd. NBR   $16   $ 39.39 $ 29.78     1/12/2006 2
National-Oilwell Varco Inc. NOV   $16   $ 64.03 $ 61.18     2/23/2006 2
ALTRIA GROUP MO   $16   $ 74.72 $ 85.82     12/30/2005 3
GENERAL MOTORS GM   $16   $ 26.50 $ 30.72     5/12/2006 3
Bancolombia S.A. (ADR) CIB   $16   $ 28.83 $ 31.13     12/30/2005 4
optionsXpress Holdings, Inc. OXPS   $16   $ 31.11 $ 22.69     3/3/2006 4
Citigroup Inc. C   $16   $ 49.40 $ 55.70     5/31/2006 4
Bank of America Corporation BAC   $16   $ 53.51 $ 53.39     12/1/2006 4
Cynosure CYNO   $16   $ 20.86 $ 15.83     12/30/2005 5
Palomar Medical Technologies, Inc. PMTI   $16   $ 39.08 $ 50.67     1/6/2006 5
Crocs, Inc. CROX   $16   $ 29.21 $ 43.20     2/16/2006 5
CRYSTALLEX INTL CORP KRY   $16   $ 5.50 $ 3.62     4/6/2006 5
Sara Lee Corp. SLE   $16   $ 18.90 $ 17.03     12/30/2005 6
Chico’s FAS, Inc. CHS   $16   $ 30.13 $ 20.69     5/9/2006 6
PepsiCo, Inc. PEP   $16   $ 62.48 $ 62.55     5/9/2006 6
Cummins Inc. CMI   $16   $ 89.73 $ 118.18     12/30/2005 7
Paccar PCAR   $16   $ 68.86 $ 64.90     2/9/2006 7
Foster Wheeler Ltd. FWLT   $16   $ 48.91 $ 55.14     5/9/2006 7
Seagate Technology STX   $16   $ 19.99 $ 26.50     12/30/2005 8
iRobot Corporation IRBT   $16   $ 28.42 $ 18.06     3/3/2006 8
Motorola, Inc. MOT   $16   $ 22.25 $ 20.56     3/29/2006 8
Ciena Corporation CIEN   $16   $ 30.87 $ 27.71     4/19/2006 8
Nokia Corporation (ADR) NOK   $16   $ 21.42 $ 20.32     5/31/2006 8
GameStop Corp. GME   $16   $ 31.82 $ 55.11     12/30/2005 9
Citi Trends, Inc. CTRN   $16   $ 42.51 $ 39.64     1/12/2006 9
                     
                     
Action_Shares_Ticker_Price Sell Date Bought Sold RealizedGain % Gain     Categories   Cat
Sold 479 CYNO @ 18.00 1/10/2006 $ 9,992.00 $ 8,622.00 $ (1,370.00) -13.7%     Company you know 1
Sold 1190 ENG @ 11.13 1/12/2006 $ 9,996.00 $ 13,244.70 $ 3,248.70 32.5%     Oil   2
Sold 314 GME @ 39.98 1/12/2006 $ 9,991.00 $ 12,239.72 $ 2,248.72 22.5%     Brand name blue chip 3
Sold 111 CMI @ 100.09 2/9/2006 $ 9,960.00 $ 11,109.99 $ 1,149.99 11.5%     Financial   4
Sold 221 PMTI @ 32.92 2/16/2006 $ 8,636.68 $ 7,275.32 $ (1,361.36) -15.8%     Speculative   5
Sold 336 NBR @ 34.335 2/23/2006 $ 13,235.04 $ 11,536.56 $ (1,698.48) -12.8%     Secular “softgoods” 6
Sold 814 VCP @ 15.21 3/3/2006 $ 10,004.06 $ 12,380.94 $ 2,376.88 23.8%     Cyclical   7
Sold 347 CIB @ 34.59 3/3/2006 $ 10,004.01 $ 12,002.73 $ 1,998.72 20.0%     Tech   8
Sold 500 STX @ 27.86 3/3/2006 $ 9,995.00 $ 13,930.00 $ 3,935.00 39.4%     Retailer   9
Sold 250 CROX @ 21.48 3/22/2006 $ 7,302.50 $ 5,370.00 $ (1,932.50) -26.5%     Non-tech “Hope” 10
Sold 180 NOV @ 59.03 3/22/2006 $ 11,525.40 $ 10,625.40 $ (900.00) -7.8%
Sold 450 IRBT @ 26.69 3/22/2006 $ 12,789.00 $ 12,010.50 $ (778.50) -6.1%
Sold 422 MOT @ 22.55 4/19/2006 $ 9,389.50 $ 9,516.10 $ 126.60 1.3%
Sold 529 SLE @ $18.20 5/9/2006 $ 9,998.10 $ 9,627.80 $ (370.30) -3.7%
Sold 161 PCAR @ $78.74 5/9/2006 $ 11,086.46 $ 12,677.14 $ 1,590.68 14.3%
Sold 134 MO @ $71.65 5/12/2006 $ 10,012.48 $ 9,601.10 $ (411.38) -4.1%
Sold 156 PCU @ 93.79 5/17/2006 $ 12,762.36 $ 14,631.24 $ 1,868.88 14.6%
Sold 277 UNH @ 42.01 5/24/2006 $ 12,082.74 $ 11,636.77 $ (445.97) -3.7%
Sold 2159 CIEND @ 3.98 5/31/2006 $ 9,521.19 $ 8,592.82 $ (928.37) -9.8%
Sold 228 FWLT @ 43.49 5/31/2006 $ 11,151.48 $ 9,915.72 $ (1,235.76) -11.1%
Sold 410 OXPS @ 28.46 5/31/2006 $ 12,755.10 $ 11,668.60 $ (1,086.50) -8.5%
Sold 1796 KRY @ 4.20 5/31/2006 $ 9,883.41 $ 7,543.20 $ (2,340.21) -23.7%
Sold 288 CTRN @ 27.84 8/1/2006 $ 12,242.88 $ 8,017.92 $ (4,224.96) -34.5%
Sold 400 CHS @ 21.37 8/2/2006 $ 12,052.00 $ 8,548.00 $ (3,504.00) -29.1%
Sold 420 GM @ 30.70 10/9/2006 $ 11,130.00 $ 12,894.00 $ 1,764.00 15.8%
Sold 133 PEP @ 62.23 10/13/2006 $ 8,309.84 $ 8,276.59 $ (33.25) -0.4%
Sold 200 C @ 49.20 12/1/2006 $ 9,880.00 $ 9,840.00 $ (40.00) -0.4%
Sold 461 NOK @ 20.36 12/5/2006 $ 9,876.62 $ 9,385.96 $ (490.66) -5.0%
Sold 185 BAC @ 52.68 12/7/2006 $ 9,899.35 $ 9,745.80 $ (153.55) -1.6%
          16% extra tax
    Net Realized Short-term capital gain   $ (2,997.58) $ (479.61) Net gain 0.3% $ 100,284.82    
          20% extra tax          
    Net Realized Short-term capital gain   $ (2,997.58) $ (599.52) Net gain 0.4% $ 100,404.72    
                     
                     
Cramer Speculative Index                    
Name Ticker _Price_Paid_ Fee Shrs Buy Price LatestPrice % Gain Total_Value Buy Date  
Rentech, Inc. RTK $ 10,000.00 $8 2,096.44 $ 4.77 $ 3.77 -21.0% $ 7,903.56 6/8/2006  
CRYSTALLEX INTL CORP KRY $ 10,000.00 $8 2,557.54 $ 3.91 $ 3.62 -7.4% $ 9,258.31 6/8/2006  
IVANHOE ENERGY INC IVAN $ 10,000.00 $8 3,831.42 $ 2.61 $ 1.35 -48.3% $ 5,172.41 6/8/2006  
Transmeridian Exploration Incorporated TMY $ 10,000.00 $8 1,834.86 $ 5.45 $ 3.45 -36.7% $ 6,330.28 6/8/2006  
NORTHGATE MINERALS CORP NXG $ 10,000.00 $8 2,976.19 $ 3.36 $ 3.48 3.6% $ 10,357.14 6/8/2006  
Lundin Mining Corporation LMC $ 9,999.99 $8 417.54 $ 23.95 $ 36.94 54.2% $ 15,424.05 6/8/2006  
JDS UNIPHASE CORP JDSU $ 10,000.00 $8 454.55 $ 22.00 $ 16.66 -24.3% $ 7,572.73 6/8/2006  
Conexant Systems, Inc. CNXT $ 10,000.00 $8 3,921.57 $ 2.55 $ 2.04 -20.0% $ 8,000.00 6/8/2006  
Finisar Corporation FNSR $ 10,000.00 $8 2,976.19 $ 3.36 $ 3.23 -3.9% $ 9,613.10 6/8/2006  
Ciena Corporation CIEN $ 10,000.00 $8 323.94 $ 30.87 $ 27.71 -10.2% $ 8,976.35 6/8/2006  
Cash   $ 0.01           $ 0.01    
    $ 100,000.00 $80       -11.5% $ 88,527.95    
                     
Cramer Luxury Index: 129                  
Name Ticker _Price_Paid_ Fee Shrs Buy Price LatestPrice % Gain Total_Value Buy Date  
Coach, Inc. COH $ 8,000.00 $8 290.28 $ 27.56 $ 42.96 55.9% $ 12,470.25 7/27/2006  
Polo Ralph Lauren Corporation RL $ 8,000.00 $8 143.47 $ 55.76 $ 77.66 39.3% $ 11,142.04 7/27/2006  
Tiffany & Co. TIF $ 8,000.00 $8 257.57 $ 31.06 $ 39.24 26.3% $ 10,106.89 7/27/2006  
Four Seasons Hotel Inc. FS $ 8,000.00 $8 152.03 $ 52.62 $ 81.99 55.8% $ 12,465.22 7/27/2006  
Orient-Express Hotels Ltd. OEH $ 8,000.00 $8 226.95 $ 35.25 $ 47.32 34.2% $ 10,739.29 7/27/2006  
Harman International Industries Inc./DE/ HAR $ 8,000.00 $8 102.56 $ 78.00 $ 99.91 28.1% $ 10,247.18 7/27/2006  
Nordstrom, Inc. JWN $ 8,000.00 $8 242.13 $ 33.04 $ 49.34 49.3% $ 11,946.73 7/27/2006  
Diageo plc (ADR) DEO $ 8,000.00 $8 115.11 $ 69.50 $ 79.31 14.1% $ 9,129.21 7/27/2006  
Toll Brothers, Inc. TOL $ 8,000.00 $8 325.47 $ 24.58 $ 32.23 31.1% $ 10,489.83 7/27/2006  
Wynn Resorts, Limited WYNN $ 8,000.00 $8 127.00 $ 62.99 $ 93.85 49.0% $ 11,919.35 7/27/2006  
Movado Group, Inc. MOV $ 8,000.00 $8 354.45 $ 22.57 $ 29.00 28.5% $ 10,279.13 7/27/2006  
Ruth’s Chris Steak House, Inc. RUTH $ 8,000.00 $8 443.70 $ 18.03 $ 18.28 1.4% $ 8,110.93 7/27/2006  
Cash   $ –           $ –    
    $ 96,000.00 $96       34.3% $ 128,950.05    
ETF vs Individual Stock                    
ML PHARMA HOLDR12/40 PPH $ 100,000.00 $8 1,333.33 $ 75.00 $ 76.95 2.6% $ 102,600.00 8/1/2006  
Pfizer Inc. PFE $ 100,000.00 $8 3,847.63 $ 25.99 $ 25.90 -0.3% $ 99,653.71 8/1/2006  
                     

The two Detailed tables compare the performance of a portfolio of broad-based Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) vs. a selection of ten of Jim
Cramer’s recent favorite stocks, one in each of ten discretionary
portfolio sectors. Each portfolio started with a pretend $100,000 on
December 30th 2005. The percent gain of each portfolio is shown, along
with a net gain for the 2006 Portfolio of Select Jim Cramer Favorite
Stocks showing the net after-extra-tax gain that has to be paid because
of short-term capital gains.

The ETF Portfolio is using the buy and hold strategy on a broad basket of equities.

For
the 2006 Portfolio of Select Jim Cramer Favorite Stocks we are choosing
stocks in ten categories based upon Jim’s suggestions. Here’s a link to Jim’s 10 Rules for Building a Portfolio. (middle of article) Another summary of that show.

Jim
is always saying that “Bulls make money, bears make money, and hogs get
slaughtered” so when we have a large gain in a stock, we tend to take
it off the table in hopes of swapping into something else that is
poised for large gains.

I gotta say, hey, the ETF Portfolio performed fantastically in the 1st quarter: up a whopping 9.6% to
$109,584.39. The Cramer portfolio struggled (victim of the Cramer
Crackle a few times) and only gained 5.6% to $105,591.98. It will do
better this next quarter, won’t it?

Second quarter update: ETF Portfolio is up 6.6% and the Cramer Portfolio is up 3.9%. Let’s hope
for an even better 2nd half of 2006.

On Wednesday, 5 July, Jim said to not to buy or to take profits in the stocks in the Speculative
Index, below. I keep it here just for reference. On 5 July it had a net
loss of 1.7%.

Here is a breakdown of what the columns mean:

Paid is the total amount of that stock we purchased.

Fee represents a typical on-line brokerage commission. Your cost may vary, typically
between $4 per trade to $20 per trade, but you may be able to find
someone even cheaper.

Shrs is the number of
pretend shares of that stock purchased. Note that we’re not buying in
round lots of 100 shares, which may affect the prices we are able to
get for the more thinly traded issues.

Buy Price is the present price we paid to purchase the stock.

LatestPrice is the last price at which the stock traded. Typically the previous day’s closing price.

% Gain shows how much of a gain (or loss) we have in the stock.

Total is the market value of the shares in that stock owned at the last trading price.

Buy Date shows the date at which the shares were added to the portfolio.

Cat is the category to which the stock belongs. LC: Large Cap, MC: Mid-Cap,
SC: Small-Cap, mC: micro-Cap, REIT: Real Estate Investment Trust, Mat:
Materials, EURO: European index, PAC: Asia/Pacific index, EM: Emerging
Market index

16% extra tax represents the typical difference between the 15% long-term capital gains rate and an
estimated 31% short-term capital gains rate (this would vary depending
upon your particular tax bracket).

Caveat: I am not a tax advisor or account or lawyer or financial planner or even a
professional spreadsheet operator. There are probably lots of mistakes
here! If you find some, I’d love to hear from you so I can fix them.
This page is just for fun and hopefully some education. As I’ve heard
somewhere before, “My job is not just to entertain you, but to educate
you. So call me at…”

To view the Backtested Portfolio of Cramer’s picks vs. the Backtested ETF portfolio, click here.